Stop Saying “Stop It!”: Why Teacher Reprimands Don’t Work — And What to Do Instead

It’s the end of a long day.Your students are restless, chatty, and off-task. You’ve tried redirecting, raising your voice, and saying, “Stop it!” more times than you can count. For a moment, it works… but five minutes later, the same behavior pops up again.

Sound familiar?You’re not alone — and according to recent research, this cycle isn’t just exhausting, it’s also ineffective.

A 2021 study by Caldarella and colleagues followed 149 teachers across 19 elementary schools and observed 311 students considered at risk for emotional and behavioral disorders (EBD). Researchers wanted to answer a simple question:

Do teacher reprimands — things like “Stop talking!” or “That’s inappropriate!” — actually work to reduce disruptive behavior or increase engagement?

The results were clear: Reprimands did NOT reduce future misbehavior. They didn’t improve student engagement. In some cases, reprimands actually predicted MORE disruptions later on. In other words, while a reprimand might stop a behavior for a moment, it won’t create lasting change.

If you’ve ever felt like you spend all day correcting behavior with little progress, this research validates your frustration.Reprimands feel like the only tool when students are off-task or disruptive — especially in chaotic moments. But over time, they can create a negative classroom cycle where:

• Students feel disconnected or targeted.

• Teachers feel drained and resentful.

• The classroom climate suffers, making misbehavior even more likely.

The good news? There are better, research-backed strategies that work with students instead of against them.

3 Proven Strategies to Replace Reprimands

1. Praise More Than You Correct

Students thrive on attention — and when we give it only for negative behaviors, those behaviors grow.Flip the script by praising desired behavior specifically and immediately:

• “Thanks for getting started right away.”

• “You’re showing great focus on your reading.”

Aim for four praise statements for every correction. Over time, this builds a positive classroom culture and motivates students to repeat those behaviors.

2. Pre-Correct Instead of Reprimand

Don’t wait for misbehavior to happen — give gentle reminders beforehand.This proactive approach helps students know what’s expected:

• “Remember, we stay seated during work time.”

• “Let’s use kind words during our group activity.”

Pre-corrections are like a GPS for your classroom — they guide students before they veer off course.

3. Build Relationships on Purpose

Students are more likely to follow expectations when they feel connected to their teacher.Simple actions go a long way:

• Greet each student by name at the door.

• Check in with students who seem withdrawn or upset.

• Celebrate their successes, even small ones.

Connection isn’t “extra” — it’s the foundation of effective classroom management.

Imagine this: Before a math lesson, Mr. Lopez notices two students whispering. Instead of saying, “Stop talking!” he takes a different approach.

First, he pre-corrects:

“In just a minute, we’re starting independent practice. Remember, that’s silent work time.”

Then, as the students get started quietly, he praises them specifically:

“Thanks for focusing right away. I appreciate that.”

Later, during dismissal, he builds connection by asking about their weekend plans.

The result? Over time, the students respond more positively to his calm, proactive approach — and disruptive behaviors decrease without constant reprimands.

Reprimands might feel like the fastest way to stop a behavior, but they don’t create lasting change.Students don’t need more corrections — they need clarity, connection, and consistency.

“While teacher reprimands may suppress misbehavior momentarily, they do not appear to be effective in decreasing students’ disruptive behavior or increasing their engagement.” — Caldarella et al., 2021

This week, try shifting from “Stop it!” to strategies that build your classroom up instead of breaking it down:

• Praise the behaviors you want to see.

• Guide students before misbehavior starts.

• Invest in relationships daily.

It’s a small shift that can transform your classroom — and your energy as a teacher.

Ready to spend less time correcting and more time connecting? Click the button below to grab your FREE copy of this Teacher Research Spotlight and learn exactly what to say — and do — to replace constant reprimands with strategies that really work.

Download now and start creating a calmer, more connected classroom today.

Download My Free Copy